Latin American women's protection after adjustment: a feminist critique of conditional cash transfers in Chile and Argentina

TABBUSH, CONSTANZA

Oxford Development Studies

ROUTLEDGE JOURNALS, TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD

Año: 2010 vol. 38 p. 437 - 459

1360-0818

Indexada en por los servicios de: CAB Abstracts, EconLit, Geographical Abstracts, Human Geography and International Bibliography of Periodical Literature. This paper analyses conditional cash transfer (CCT) policies in Argentina and Chile from a gender perspective. Policy advocates maintain that, through the income provided by CCTs, women acquire some economic autonomy and empowerment within the household. This positive analysis is, however, tempered by gender-based concerns about the developmental value of conservative appeals to women as ?mothers?, founded on traditional cultural norms, in regional policy design. Drawing on these two country examples, the objective of the paper is to assess the terms and conditions of women?s inclusion as ?conduits of policy? in CCTs in the Southern Cone. Findings indicate that the continuity of policy in Chile?s anti-poverty strategies locates women as being accountable for family well-being within a multidimensional and psychological vision of poverty. Chile constitutes a radical example of the extension of women?s individual responsibilities in managing household poverty with no collective component. By contrast, in Argentina the role of women appears to be dictated more by continuous changes in the state?s definition of poverty alleviation, rather than the developmental objective of empowering women. Women?s positioning in CCTs could be labelled as bearers of politics, in a context that transfers to women the duty of socially assisting others while rendering their personal needs progressively less visible.