Comentario del artículo: "Violence and perimortem signaling among early irrigation communities in the Sonoran desert"

WATSON, JAMES T.; PHELPS, DANIELLE O.; EDELTRAUD ASPÖCK; LYNNE GOLDSTEIN; GORDÓN, FLORENCIA; PATRICIA M. LAMBERT; WIESLAW WIECKOWSKI

CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY

The University of Chicago Press

Año: 2016 vol. 57 p. 602 - 602

0011-3204

Participación en calidad de comentarista del trabajo de Watson & Phelps:Violence is common among small-scale societies and often stems from a combination of exogenous and endogenous factors. We suggest that socialization for violence and revenge as a motivation can encourage costly signaling by warriors and contribute to the creation of atypical burials in archaeological contexts. We characterize mortuary patterns among early irrigation communities in the Sonoran Desert of the southwest United States/northwest Mexico (Early Agricultural period: 2100 BC?AD 50) to define normative mortuary practices and identify atypical burials. One of the principle roles the performance of mortuary rituals fulfills is to publicly integrate a shared identity or reinforce social differences within a community. This postmortem negotiation of social identities was likely an important component to ease social tensions in early farming communities. However, atypical burials from these sites appear to represent acts of violence upon the corpse at, or after, the death of the individual that fall outside of the normative conformity to prescribed mortuary ritual. We propose that these cases represent perimortem signaling, a form of costly signaling conditioned as basal violent reactions, possibly stemming from socialization for violence.