Dialectical Inferences in the Construction of Social Domain Knowledge

HORN, AXEL; CASTORINA, JOSÉ ANTONIO; BARREIRO, ALICIA

Human Arenas

Springer

Año: 2023

2522-5790

The category of dialectical inferences was proposed by Piaget to interpret the inferences arising in the coordination of meanings within the construction of cognitive novelties in physical and logical-mathematical phenomena. First, the different uses given to the concept of dialectics in Piagetian work will be analyzed, emphasizing the original meaning of the term “inferential dialectical”. Second, the results of a study on the construction of children´s ideas about the right to privacy at school will be analyzed using the category of dialectical inferences. This study was based on interviews with 30 children between 7 and 12 years old living in the City of Buenos Aires to study the development of their ideas about this right. At the same time, we observed the school practices in which these children participate to characterize how students´ personal information was treated at school. Thirdly, we propose a discussion on the construction of social knowledge, identifying the constructive activity of subjects and, at the same time, the peculiar interactions they sustain with social practices from which the object of knowledge is cut out. In this article we conclude that the category of dialectical inferences, used to investigate the development of physical and mathematical logical knowledge, can be fruitful to interpret the development of social ideas.