El Dilema Discursivo: El comportamiento de la gente y los efectos del Marco

BODANZA, GUSTAVO; DELBIANCO, FERNANDO ANDRÉS; FREIDIN, ESTEBAN; LINARES, SEBASTIÁN

Congreso; V Congreso Internacional en Argumentación; 2017

We report a series of experiments of anold dilemma in judgment aggregation (Kornhauserand Sager, 1986, 1992, 1993). The subjects were 443 undergraduate students from different courses at Universidad Nacional del Sur, Argentina. The experiment´s results confirmed the existenceof framing effects. In contrast with the results reported byBonnefon (2010), subjects not always chose the deliberation style promoting themost benevolent outcome for the candidate. Henceforth, we have a negativeresult for the hypothesis that the election of deliberation style dependsstraightforwardly on the most benevolent outcome.