Socioeconomic processes as open-ended results. Beyond invariance knowledge for interventionist purposes

IVAROLA LEONARDO

THEORIA

Universidad del País Vasco

Lugar: Donostia; Año: 2017 vol. 32 p. 211 - 229

0495-4548

In this paper a critique to Cartwright?s approaches of capacities and nomological machines is carried out. This approaches share the idea that invariant knowledge is crucial for achieving policy purposes. However, it is shown that socioeconomic processes do not fit to the logic of stable causal factors, but they are more suited to the logic of ?open-ended results?. On the basis of this ontological variation it is argued that ex-ante interventions are not appropriate in the socioeconomic realm. On the contrary, they must be understood in a ?dynamic? sense. Finally, derivational robustness analysis is proposed as a useful tool for overcoming the problem of ?overconstraint?, a typical problem of economic models.