Performance epistemology and pragmatic intrusion: Some general connections applied to the sosa’s theory. Epistemología del desempeño e intrusión pragmática: Algunas conexiones generales aplicadas a la teoría de sosa

RIMOLDI, FLORENCIA

TRANS/FORM/AçãO

UNIVERSIDADE ESTADUAL PAULISTA (UNESP)

Año: 2021 vol. 44 p. 97 - 126

0101-3173

In this paper, I will explore the connections between two salient positions in contemporary epistemology: Performance-based epistemology and pragmatic encroachment in epistemology, paying special attention to Sosa´s theory of knowledge and the arguments put forward by Stanley (2015) and Fantl and McGrath (2011). In the first section, I will review both positions. In the second section, I will try to answer a question that has been barely explored in the literature on virtues: Can a performance-based theory make room for pragmatic encroachment? I will claim that there are at least two ways in which this could occur. In the third section I will take Sosa?s discussion on the topic of pragmatic encroachment found in Judgment and Agency chapter 8, and I will argue that while Sosa?s rejection of pragmatic encroachment forces him to assume unnecessarily deep theoretical problems that are hard to solve, his theory can accommodate pragmatic encroachment in a natural way.