INVESTIGADORES
CLERICO Maria Laura
congresos y reuniones científicas
Título:
Lack of regional consensus in human rights argumentation. ECtHR and the IACtHR in divergence
Autor/es:
CLÉRICO LAURA
Lugar:
Erlangen
Reunión:
Workshop; Research in Contemporary Legal History and Human Rights at FAU. Workshop with Delegation of Lawers and Judges from Brasil; 2018
Institución organizadora:
International Criminal Law Research Unit (ICLU)
Resumen:
Structure of the presentation.Why comparative law in HHRR adjudication? The double mission of the Courts. The tension. The clutch: Existence of european consensus (EoE) as accelerator. Lack of consensus (LoC) as restraint. ?Transfer? to IACtHR?Two meanings. Two functions (descriptive and correctness). Argumentative relation: EoE /LoC and Margin of Aprecciation (MoA). Three problems. The insufficiency problem.Lack of regional consensus in the question of same sex marriage. Two answers: divergence between ECtHR (restraint) and IACtHR (argumentation without ties).Conclusions. Hypothesis. The quest of legitimacy. Audiences.
