Early Holocene Human Remains from the Argentinean Pampas, Cranial Variation in South America and the American Peopling

MENÉNDEZ, L.P.; PÉREZ, S. I.; PUCCIARELLI, H. M.; BONOMO, M.; MESSINEO, P. G.; GONZALEZ, M. E.; POLITIS, G.

PaleoAmerica

W. S. Maney & Son Ltd and the Center for the Study of the First Americans

Año: 2015 vol. 1 p. 251 - 265

2055-5563

Morphological comparisons between the earliest and latest human skeletons of America have suggested the existence of a complex scenario underlying the biological diversification of American populations. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries Florentino Ameghino initiated the debate on the antiquity of humans of the Argentinean Pampas. The importance of this region has been reviewed recently in the context of the diversification of American populations due to recent radiocarbon dates obtained from nine samples of human bones studied by Ameghino and other Argentinean researchers. Morphometric analyses from these Argentinean Pampas samples are presented together with other early samples from Chile, Brazil,and Colombia, with all early samples being compared with late Holocene samples by region. Results show that while there is no clear separation between early and late samples from Chile, the samples from Brazil, Colombia, and Argentina show more pronounced differences. Argentinean Pampas samples present the largest morphological variation when plotted against other early American samples. However, the hypotheses that the morphological differences between early and late American samples are related to migration, drift, natural selection, or other processes are difficult to support using cranial morphometric differences alone. Future studies need to consider more evidence (e.g., archaeological, molecular, among others) combined.