INVESTIGADORES
POLITIS Gustavo Gabriel
artículos
Título:
Some Opinions about Monte Verde: Response to Dillehay (2019) and Dillehay, Pino, and Ocampo (2020)
Autor/es:
POLITIS, GUSTAVO G.; PRATES, LUCIANO
Revista:
PaleoAmerica
Editorial:
Taylor and Francis.
Referencias:
Lugar: Nueva York; Año: 2020 vol. 20 p. 3 - 12
ISSN:
2055-5563
Resumen:
This article is a response to Dillehay [2019. ?Un ensayo sobre genética, arqueología y movilidad humana temprana.? Mundo de Antes 13 (2): 13?65] and Dillehay, Pino, and Ocampo [2020. ?Comments on Archaeological Remains at the Monte Verde Site Complex, Chile.? PaleoAmerica. https://doi.org/10.1080/20555563.2020.1762399], who criticized our comments about Monte Verde-I and Chinchihuapi-I as well as our suggestion of the tightening of the age of Monte Verde-II [Politis, G. G., and L. Prates. 2018. ?Clocking the Arrival of Homo sapiens in the Southern Cone of South America.? In New Perspectives on the Peopling of the Americas, edited by K. Harvati, G. Jäger, and H. Reyes Centeno, 79?106. Tübingen: Kerns Verlag]. They claimed that we purposefully ignored pertinent data to support our opinions, and that we made several mistakes when analyzing the evidence. In this article we demonstrate that we did not ignore any relevant data, and that the putative errors are in fact alternative interpretations based on the available data and recent studies about site formation processes.