CONICET | Buscador de Institutos y Recursos Humanos

Background: The causes for the higher biodiversity in the Neotropics as compared to the Nearctic and the factors promoting species diversification in both regions have been much debated. The refuge hypothesis posits that high tropical diversity reflects high speciation rates, but this conclusion has been challenged. The present study investigates this matter by examining continental patterns of avian diversification through the analysis of large-scale DNA barcode libraries. Methodology and Principal Findings: Standardized COI datasets from the avifaunas of Argentina, the Nearctic and the Palearctic were analyzed. Average genetic distances between closest congeners and sister species were higher in Argentina than in North America reflecting a much higher percentage of recently diverged species in the latter region. In the Palearctic genetic distances appeared to be more similar to those of the southern Neotropics. Average intraspecific variation was slightly lower in Argentina than in North America, while the Palearctic fauna had the highest value due to a higher percentage of variable species. Geographic patterning of intraspecific structure was more complex in the southern Neotropics than in the Nearctic, while the Palearctic showed an intermediate level of complexity.. Conclusions and significance: DNA barcodes can reveal continental patterns of diversification. Our analysis suggests that avian species are older in Argentina than in the Nearctic, supporting the idea that the greater diversity of the Neotropical avifauna is not due to higher speciation rates. Species in the Palearctic also appear to be older than those in the Nearctic. These results, combined with the patterns of geographic structuring found in each region, suggest a major impact of Pleistocene glaciations in the Nearctic, a lesser effect in the Palearctic and a mild effect in the southern Neotropics.